A.R.
[The following is a very opinionated rant (and a bit rambling and disjointed)...]
A.R. is what is called Accelerated Reader. You can read about it at the AR website or the Wikipedia Page.
Does the schools of any of your kids use this program? What do you think about it. I mean what do you REALLY think about it?
My personal opinion is that it is a wonderful tool for the young kids. Earning points and prizes are great motivators for most young kids. Then, suddenly any fun that was there gets sucked away from it and it becomes the worst chore ever.
Alex went through this at the school system here. She started with second grade when we moved here and they did it clear through sixth grade. It was more exciting to be out of sixth grade and be done forever with AR than for any other reason. Period. Seriously.
Now, Alex has always been a ferocious reader. She devours books in fact. The problem that she started to have with the whole program is that the books she was reading weren’t usually included in the AR structure. At third grade, she was reading at a 9-10th grade reading level and most of the books were geared to a 6-7th grade level, but usually lower than that. She HATED AR with a passion that she doesn’t show often. (She still does, but is thankful that it is no longer forced down her throat on a daily basis.)
I was talking with some other Moms about it this week and it seems that my opinion is not singular. It was at that moment that I realized that I have to go through it all over again with Phoebe, but starting with Kindergarten rather then second grade
I noticed on the website for the company that sells it that one of their highlights is that it will “build a lifelong love of reading and learning.” I have news for you AR people, I have met a lot of students which it did the opposite for. And, these are good, high achieving students that would rather stick nails under their fingernails than to read for pleasure all thanks to AR. I so dread that this might be a possibility for Phoebe. Alex at least still reads.
Oh, how I wish they would stop using it so intently. It really feels as if their entire reading curriculum is based completely on this program. Why? I don’t know. But, I really wonder. Maybe it needs better tailoring or implementation. I personally believe it should be used as a tool, not a focus of the curriculum.
Which makes me curious of what people in other districts, states, countries might think about it.
So, do your schools use it? Do you think they use it well?







